Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Ron Renzy
Coral Springs, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 32 years of experience
(954) 757-1212
4613 North University Drive
#290
Coral Springs, FL 33067
Free ConsultationAppeals
Stetson University College of Law
Ron is an appellate attorney who, over the course of his 30 plus year legal career, has handled client appeals in both the state and federal appellate courts, which includes matters before the United States Supreme Court.
As a long-time Florida resident, growing up in Sunrise, Florida, Ron began his career after graduating from Stetson University College of Law in 1992. He practiced law for four years in South Florida before forming a partnership with attorney Wendy Wallberg in 1996. During their 25-year law practice, Wallberg & Renzy, P.A., offered appellate, civil, and commercial litigation services to clients in the state...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Stephen Thomas Allen
Coral Springs, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 10 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Administrative and Immigration
University of Miami School of Law
I graduated from the University of Miami School of Law in December 2013. I then took the Florida Bar Exam in February 2014, and I have been practicing law ever since my April 2014 admission to the Florida Bar.
I have learned how to use my legal knowledge in order to generate a fair result in my cases. Immigration law is one of the most pressing civil rights concerns of our time period. Frequently, fair results do require fights.
I am not afraid of fighting hard for my clients before Government...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Michael Gulisano
Coral Springs, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney
(954) 947-3972
5645 Coral Ridge Drive, Suite 207
Coral Springs, FL 33076
Appeals and Consumer
St. Thomas University School of Law
Michael Gulisano received a Juris Doctor from St. Thomas University School of Law in 2010. Mr. Gulisano graduated magna cum laude and finished in the top 7% of his class (13 out of a class of 183).
While in law school, Mr. Gulisano was an editor for the St. Thomas Law Review. Before attending law school, Mr. Gulisano received a Bachelor of Arts from the University of Central Florida where he majored in Art and Communications and minored in English Writing.
After passing the Florida bar, Mr. Gulisano worked as an associate for several large, medium, and small-sized firms for several years....
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Matthew Fornaro
Coral Springs, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 21 years of experience
(954) 324-3651
11555 Heron Bay Blvd Ste 200
Coral Springs, FL 33076-3362
Appeals, Arbitration & Mediation, Business and Real Estate
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawg SearchSocial Media
Michael Cohen
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 48 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals and White Collar Crime
Cumberland School of Law, Samford University and New York University Law School
Michael B Cohen is an experienced Fort Lauderdale Criminal Defense Attorney.
He specializes in the defense trial appeal and post conviction relief of Federal Criminal cases as well as State Criminal cases.
He is a former Assistant United States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida and a former Assistant State Attorney in Broward County Florida.
Mr.Cohen is also a board certified criminal defense lawyer, AV rated by Martindale Hubbel and is regularly listed in the annual editions of Florida Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers in America
As a former prosecutor with 43 years of overall experience...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Sean William Conway
Oakland Park, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 28 years of experience
Appeals
The Florida State University College of Law
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Daniel Bushell
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 22 years of experience
(954) 666-0220
6400 N. Andrews Avenue
Suite 505
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309
Appeals
University of Pennsylvania Law School
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ABlawg SearchSocial Media
Jason M. Melton
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 22 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Insurance Claims, White Collar Crime and Workers' Comp
The Catholic University of America
Attorney Jason M. Melton, is a founding partner of Whittel & Melton. As a former state prosecutor, he continues fighting for victims bringing in some of the largest single event results in Central Florida.
Jason is a lifetime member of the Multi-Million and Million Dollar Advocates Forum, AV-Rated by Martindale-Hubbell and continues to be listed among SuperLawyers in Florida by Thomson Reuters. He is a Founding Member of the National Academy of Motorcycle Injury Lawyers, and in 2023 was named President.
Attorney Melton is dedicated to providing clients with personalized, high-quality representation. We handle Auto Accidents, Slip and Fall, Injury, Nursing...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Frederick A. Neustein
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 32 years of experience
(888) 400-2889
110 East Broward Blvd
Suite 1700
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Free ConsultationAppeals, Bankruptcy, Business and Real Estate
University of Miami School of Law
Frederick A. Neustein, a Miami native of 56 years, has been a licensed attorney in the State of Florida for 31 years. Mr. Neustein, together with the staff at NLG, have been responsible for defending Thousands of foreclosure cases across the state of Florida and saving 1000's homes.
For twelve years, Mr. Neustein worked “for the Banks” in the Mortgage Banking Industry for various Institutional Investment Banks. Mr. Neustein served as Vice President and counsel for American Residential Equities (ARE) headquartered in Miami-Dade County, which acquired approximately $1 Billion in residential and commercial mortgages.
At ARE, Mr. Neustein was primarily responsible for...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Tom Hunker
FORT LAUDERDALE, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney
Free ConsultationAppeals and Insurance Defense
Florida State University College of Law
Tom Hunker is a Board Certified, AV Rated appellate attorney with many years of experience at the trial and appellate levels. Tom has successfully briefed and argued numerous appeals in state and federal courts in a broad range of practice areas. Throughout his career, clients and other lawyers and law firms have relied on Tom's knowledge and expertise in formulating litigation strategies and presenting winning arguments.
Prior to founding Hunker Appeals, Tom graduated law school magna cum laude, interned for the Florida House of Representatives, clerked for the Florida Supreme Court, served as in house appellate counsel for a motor vehicle...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawg SearchSocial Media
David M. Edelstein
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 29 years of experience
Appeals, Administrative and White Collar Crime
University of Miami School of Law
David Edelstein is an AV® rated criminal defense attorney representing clients facing criminal charges in both state and federal courts throughout the State of Florida. Mr. Edelstein started his career as a criminal lawyer in Miami at the Miami-Dade County Public Defender's Office and has been in private practice for the past 20 years. He has defended clients facing criminal charges in Florida from Jacksonville to Key West and from Portland, Oregon to New York City. Although he has occasionally represented clients on appeal, Mr. Edelstein spends the majority of his time as a criminal trial attorney.
“Our firm’s criminal...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawg SearchSocial Media
Robert G. Whittel
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 23 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Bankruptcy, Immigration and Products Liability
University of Cambridge and University of Florida Levin College of Law
An experienced trial attorney, Robert Whittel provides his clients with strong, disciplined, results-oriented representation. Prior to becoming a lawyer, he served as a Lieutenant Commander in the US Navy. Robert graduated from both law school and the United States Merchant Marine Academy with honors, and served on the esteemed Florida Law Review. Before co-founding Whittel & Melton, a full-service law firm, Robert gained valuable experience in the court room both serving as a former prosecutor and representing large corporations in complex litigation and transactional matters. Robert is devoted to fighting for his clients’ rights. He handles all types of criminal...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ASocial MediaResponsive Law
Patricia C. Wall-Santiago
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 20 years of experience
Appeals, Administrative and Immigration
Interamerican University of Puerto Rico School of Law and Universidad Complutense de Madrid
Ms. Patricia C. Wall is an energetic and passionate attorney. She received her law degree in June 2003 from the Interamerican University School of Law. In May 2004, after passing her bar exam and being admitted to practice law by the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico, she started working for a former INS prosecutor, giving her a vast understanding and experience with US immigration and nationality laws.
When it comes to helping, guiding, and counseling clients from all walks of life and more than 15 countries, Attorney Wall attributes her success to her multicultural education, multilingual background, and extensive immigration experience....
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
John Faro
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 55 years of experience
Appeals, IP, Patents and Trademarks
Boston University School of Law
Mr. Faro is Boston born and educated. Faro has been a Registered Patent Attorney since 1971; and, since then. has continuously represented inventors (and their companies) in the protection, exploitation and enforcement of intellectual property rights throughout the U. S.
Prior to entering private practice Faro was the patent counsel for the Baxter Healthcare three (3) divisions, in Miami, Florida (immuno-diagnostics), and in Costa Mesa, California (clinical chemistry) and in the Stanford, Connecticut (Wappler Endoscopic Instruments)
In private practice, Mr. Faro has represented his former employer, Baxter Healthcare, IVAX Inc., C.R. Bard. Polaroid Corp., Meridian Diagnostics, Coulter Diagnostics,...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Nicole (Neustein) Moskowitz
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 16 years of experience
(888) 400-2889
110 East Broward Blvd
Suite 1700
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Free ConsultationAppeals, Business, Products Liability and Real Estate
University of Miami School of Law
Nicole (Neustein) Moskowitz is a Miami native who has been licensed to practice law since 2008. After law school, Ms. Moskowitz worked for a major law firm in which she defended multi-million dollar insurance and products liability cases. Ms. Moskowitz also has extensive courtroom experience as both a litigator and federal law clerk.
Ms. Moskowitz brings a unique experience to the practice of law having completed prestigious clerkships for two federal magistrate judges in the Southern District of Florida. These clerkships exposed Ms. Moskowitz to the inner workings of a court room and a variety of federal cases including civil rights...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Kenneth B. Schwartz
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 24 years of experience
Appeals, Employment and Workers' Comp
University of Hawai'i at Manoa William S. Richardson School of Law
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial MediaResponsive Law
Maikel Nagy Eskander
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 13 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Business, Real Estate and Trademarks
Florida State University College of Law
Mr. Eskander is an AV Preeminent rated attorney with Capital Partners Law PLLC. He is a dynamic leader, both within the firm and the local business community. As a true legal ambassador to the corporate world, he is passionate about helping individuals and companies succeed in a global economy while maintaining focus on integrity, honesty, high personal ethics, and creating an atmosphere of cooperation & teamwork.
As a business, real estate, and litigation attorney, Mr. Eskander prides himself on being a zealous advocate and trusted advisor to his clients. His knowledge and understanding of the law, combined with his ability...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial MediaResponsive Law
Carl Berry
For Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 28 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals and Business
North Carolina Central University School of Law
At the Strategic Legal Group, we excel in offering comprehensive and strategic counsel to businesses, safeguarding the legal interests of both domestic and international enterprises. Our core competency lies in steering corporate entities towards legal adherence and resolutions across a broad spectrum in the drafting, evaluation, and advisory services related to contracts spanning various crucial areas. This includes commercial transactions, commercial property and business acquisitions, scrutiny and negotiation of commercial leases, marketing agreements, vendor agreements, technology and software licensing (including SaaS agreements), employment contracts, termination agreements, confidentiality and non-compete agreements, adherence to building codes (including ADA compliance), facilitating mergers and...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Joshua R. Kon
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 16 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Business and Real Estate
Nova Southeastern University
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Brian J. Holland
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney
Free ConsultationAppeals, Employment, Products Liability and Trademarks
Nova Southeastern University
Brian Holland grew up just North of Tampa, Florida in Spring Hill before receiving a degree in marketing from the University of Central Florida. During his time in Orlando, Brian worked for professional and amateur sports organizations such as the Orlando Predators, Major League Lacrosse, Miami Marlins, and University of Central Florida Athletics. Brian attended Nova Southeastern University where he attained his Juris Doctor Degree. Brian has spent time volunteering and raising money for organizations such as Habitat for Humanity, Team Red, White & Blue, and the FDNY Foundation. Brian prides himself on supporting current and...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Michael Perry Mirer
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 27 years of experience
(954) 573-1354
110 East Broward Boulevard #1700
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Appeals and White Collar Crime
Michael Mirer is a seasoned criminal defense lawyer in Miami-Dade, Florida. His firm, the Law Office of Michael Mirer, P.A., handles all types of misdemeanor, felony, and federal charges. Michael earned his Juris Doctor from the University of Miami School of Law and was licensed by the Florida State Bar in 1997. Michael served as a Miami-Dade County Assistant State Attorney before entering into private practice. His experience on both sides of the courtroom helps him build comprehensive defenses and seek the best possible results for each client. Michael has defended a number of high profile cases...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Shannon McLin
Ft. Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 31 years of experience
(866) 352-7732
One Financial Plaza
Floor 1000
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33394
Appeals
Pepperdine University School of Law
Shannon McLin founded a boutique appellate law firm after serving as a staff attorney at Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeal. In 2019, she opened Florida Appeals, a statewide appellate firm with seven appellat lawyers practicing complex civil appellate litigation throughout Florida. A significant portion of her work is the family law arena.
Ms. McLin is board-certified in appellate practice and is a certified circuit court and appellate mediator. She is AV Preiminant rated by Martindale-Hubbell and has consistently been selected as one of Florida Trend's Legal Elite and as a Florida Superlawyer in appellate practice. Ms....
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Justin C. Carlin
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 15 years of experience
(954) 440-0901
1401 E. Broward Boulevard
Suite 101
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Appeals, Arbitration & Mediation, Business and Real Estate
Florida International University College of Law
Justin C. Carlin, founder of The Carlin Law Firm, PLLC, in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, is a state and federal business, real estate, and civil trial attorney. Justin is rated AV Preeminent® by Martindale-Hubbell—the highest rating available. In each of the past five years, he has also been named a “Florida Rising Star” by Super Lawyers® magazine—an honor limited to no more than 2.5% of Florida attorneys. In 2016, he became a fellow of the American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA) National Trial College at Harvard Law School.
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Erich C. Ferrari
Ft. Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 17 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals
St. Mary's University School of Law
As the principal partner at Ferrari & Associates, P.C., Washington D.C. attorney Erich C. Ferrari offers legal guidance in the areas of sanctions law, federal criminal defense and federal employment law. Attorney Ferrari has offered counsel in many matters before the Office of Foreign Assets Control. He is regularly called upon to speak on sanctions law concerns by media outlets and other organizations. Mr. Ferrari received his undergraduate degree from Purdue University and his Juris Doctor from the St. Mary’s School of Law. Visit his firm’s website or call them today to arrange for a consultation.
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Steven Jay Greenstein
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 51 years of experience
Appeals, Arbitration & Mediation and Products Liability
New England Law | Boston
Aggressive Advocate Focus on Trial and Appellate Litigation Represent Plaintiffs Multi-Jurisdiction Bar Admission in State and Federal Courts
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Susana Rodriguez
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer
Appeals, Business, Insurance Defense and Workers' Comp
St. Thomas University School of Law
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Matthew T. Moore
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 15 years of experience
(954) 908-7766
330 N. Andrews Avenue
Suite 450
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Appeals, Business, Consumer and Products Liability
Shepard Broad Law Center, Nova Southeastern University
Matthew's practice is diverse. From the plaintiff's world of class action, mass torts, product liability, and catastrophic injury, to civil appellate practice over a wide range of subject. He also acts as an on-call "in-house counsel" to growing businesses. Matthew spent the first 15 years of his career in Boston and Los Angeles as a marketing and management executive, before graduating summa cum laude from the Shepard Broad Law Center at Nova Southeastern University in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. He was also editor in chief of the Nova Law Review and received the Student Bar Association's Award for Academic...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Jon Polenberg
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 21 years of experience
Appeals, Arbitration & Mediation, Business and Real Estate
University of Miami School of Law
Before his career as an attorney, for 16 years Mr. Polenberg successfully pursued a business management career, which included his tenure as a regional manager for Cintas Corporation. Mr. Polenberg managed the region by recruiting, training, developing, and producing sales and profit, which provides Mr. Polenberg with insight to the business challenges facing today's companies. Using his business experience, Mr. Polenberg became a lawyer with the prestigious law firm of Weil Gotshal & Manges LLP, and then started his own firm in the summer of 2005, now known as Polenberg Cooper, P.A. As a result, Mr. Polenberg has civil litigation...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Blair Fazzio
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney
Appeals
University of Miami
Blair M. Fazzio is a Partner at Kanner & Pintaluga. Her practice focuses on overseeing all personal injury and property damage appellate proceedings at the Firm. She handles all types of civil appellate matters, including extraordinary writs and plenary appeals in state courts, as well as providing litigation and trial support to preserve the record for appeal.
Blair began her legal career clerking for the Honorable Angel A. Cortiñas at Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal. Prior to joining Kanner & Pintaluga, she served as lead appellate counsel at the Office of the Assistant Attorney General of Florida where she argued...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Austin Carr
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 40 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Business, Employment and Insurance Defense
Whittier Law School
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Kenneth Eric Trent
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 23 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Consumer, Insurance Claims and Real Estate
Nova Southeastern University
Kenneth Trent is a civil trial lawyer who has served Broward and surrounding counties for over 15 years. He practices in areas such as foreclosure defense, and civil litigation.
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Randy Berman
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 43 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals and White Collar Crime
Drake University Law School
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Matthew Kish
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 28 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals, Bankruptcy and Business
California Western School of Law and Arizona State University
Matthew Kish is an attorney with substantial experience in all aspects of bankruptcy, real estate, and commercial law. Matthew has practiced law in California and Florida and he has a proven ability to find sound solutions to complex legal, commercial, and financial concerns. Originally from Philadelphia, he is an avid surfer and outdoorsman.
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Harrison R DuBosar
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 7 years of experience
Appeals, Business, IP and Securities
Florida State University College of Law
Harrison DuBosar is an associate at The DuBosar Law Group, P.A. Mr. DuBosar’s practice focuses on commercial litigation and appeals. Mr. DuBosar graduated from the Florida State University College of Law where he was the Treasurer of the Moot Court Board and an Associate Justice of the student Supreme Court. During law school, Mr. DuBosar was also a member of the Journal of Transnational Law and Policy and the Journal of Land Use and Environmental Law, where he was awarded Best Sub Citer. Additionally, Mr. DuBosar won the Best Brief Award and was a semi-finalist at the 2017 Kaufman Moot...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Sophia NS Blair
Oakland Park, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 15 years of experience
(954) 326-4723
2701 W. Oakland Park Blvd.
Ste. 410-14
Oakland Park, FL 33311
Appeals and Real Estate
Thank you for your time and consideration.
I am the founder of SNSB Law Firm. We handle real estate transactions, curative and appeals. If you have a real estate related question or concern, there are answers to FAQs under the Real Estate section of our website (snsblaw.com) as well as a blog filled with case law and articles relevant to real estate matters. Of course, you may also contact our office for one-on-one assistance with your real estate matter.
I have been practicing law for over a decade, and I look forward to assisting you in any way that I...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Robert W. Stickney
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 33 years of experience
(954) 767-8908
One Financial Plaza Suite 2510
100 SE 3rd Ave
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33394
Appeals, Business, Consumer and IP
University of Florida
Robert Stickney's career is one devoted to serving justice and country. He has held key positions on both sides of the court room as a State Attorney and Assistant United States Attorney and as criminal defense attorney handling serious crimes in both state and federal court. In addition to his impressive record as an effective litigator, both in and out of court, Mr. Stickney also has a distinguished career in the United States Navy as a naval officer where he has risen to his current command level rank of Captain.
Mr. Stickney is a South Florida native. He graduated...
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Julie Prag Vianale
Boca Raton, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 39 years of experience
Appeals, Consumer and White Collar Crime
University of Virginia
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Stephen R. Verbit
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney with 37 years of experience
(954) 965-8350
2900 East Oakland Park Boulevard
Third Floor
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33306
Appeals, Business, Consumer and Environmental
The George Washington University Law School
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Eric Clayman
Ft. Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Attorney
500 East Broward Blvd.
Suite 1820
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33394
Appeals and White Collar Crime
Eric Clayman is a criminal defense lawyer in Fort Lauderdale who has a background in both law enforcement and as a prosecutor. Mr. Clayman graduated from the Washtenaw County Police Academy with top honors in marksmanship, physical fitness, and defensive driving tactics. He began his legal career as a Certified Legal Intern (CLI) for the Broward County State Attorney’s Office.
In addition to a tenure as a certified police officer in Hamtramck, Michigan, Mr. Clayman also worked in the Broward County Public Defender’s Office and the Office of the Criminal Conflict and Civil Regional Counsel for the Fourth District. Mr. Clayman's...
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawg SearchSocial MediaResponsive Law
Kenneth David Padowitz
Fort Lauderdale, FL Appeals & Appellate Lawyer with 38 years of experience
Free ConsultationAppeals and White Collar Crime
Shepard Broad Law Center, Nova Southeastern University
Kenneth Padowitz is a 36 year Criminal Defense Trial Lawyer and is one of the Top Florida Trial Lawyers. He has a Resume on paper and experience unmatched by any other Criminal Defense Attorney in the Southeastern United States. Ken has been a lawyer for over thirty-five years and has tried over 300 jury trials and 35 first-degree murder trials with a 34/1 win loss record in murder trials. Trial is always the last resort. It is only by doing the in-court and out-of-court work from a real experienced trial lawyer, that the best alternative options to trial materialize. ...